A D V E N T U R E S   in   C Y B E R S O U N D

The Camera Obscura : Aristotle to Zahn


Camera obscura (||Cam"e*ra ob*scu"ra) [LL. camera chamber + L. obscurus, obscura, dark.] (Opt.)

1. An apparatus in which the images of external objects, formed by a convex lens or a concave mirror, are thrown on a paper or other white surface placed in the focus of the lens or mirror within a darkened chamber, or box, so that the outlines may be traced.

2. (Photog.) An apparatus in which the image of an external object or objects is, by means of lenses, thrown upon a sensitized plate or surface placed at the back of an extensible darkened box or chamber variously modified; - commonly called simply the camera.

Websters Dictionary, 1913
http://www.bibliomania.com


The first casual reference [to the Camera Obscura] is by Aristotle (Problems, ca 330 BC), who questions how the sun can make a circular image when it shines through a square hole. Euclid's Optics (ca 300 BC), presupposes the camera obscura as a demonstration that light travels in straight lines. Egnacio Danti in commentary on his translation of Euclid's Optica (1573), adds a description of the camera obscura.

By this time knowledge of the camera obscura is already firmly established in Italy, with the availability of Giovanni Battista della Porta's Magica Naturalis (1558), based on earlier books (Cesare Caesariano's translation and commentary to Vitruvius's Architecture (1521), Francesco Maurolico's Theorameta de Lumine et Umbra (1521), Erasamus Reinholt in commentary in translation of Plubach's Theoricae Novae Planatarum 1542, and others).

Porta's second edition of Magia Naturalis (1591) includes a lens for the camera. This had been suggested earlier by Roger Bacon, and was in use by others in the 16th century. Porta popularized the camera obscura, which was instantly in use with astronomers: Kepler, solar observations, 1600, including the transit of Mercury in 1606; Fabricius, sunspots, 1611. Kepler coined the term "camera obscura."

the article continues...

Porta's Natural Magic was published in English in 1658. In the same year Kepler's design for a camara obscura drawing tent was available in English. The reflex box camera (using a mirror to invert the image) is described in Oculus Artificialis Teledioptricus, 1658 by Johann Zann, as well as the use of a telephoto lens (Galilean). This was used also by Kepler in 1600 - 1610 (Dioptrice, 1611). The telephoto lens design has not changed to today.

A Camera Obscura designed for viewing (and drawing) is described by Robert Boyle in On the Systematic or Cosmical Qualities of Things (1670), which includes a focussing front, a lens, and viewing back. Robert Hooke describes the opaque projector in Philosophical Transactions 1668. By the beginning of the 18th century the viewing camera obscura was commercially for sale in London (see John Harris, Lexicon Technicum, 1704), known at the time as 'Scioptricks', after the lens which was known as a 'scioptric ball.'

and closes...

Abu Ali Al-hasen Ibn Alhasen, mathematician, born in Basra, d. 1038 Cairo, claimed he could control the inundations of the Nile, for which caliph Hakim ordered him to Cairo in 1015 or 1017. Realizing his abilities as civil engineer were less than his skill as a mathematician, he feigned insanity to save his head.

Until Hakim died in 1021, Alhazen spent his time at the library of Alexandria, writing on geometry, optics, perspective and the camera obscura. Translated into Latin in 1270 and printed as Opticae Thesaurus Alhazani in 1572. MSS at Paris, Oxford, Leyden. An additional MS at the Vatican Library is annotated by Lorenzo Ghiberti of the Florence Baptistry doors (1378 - 1455). Earlier MSS may have existed, for Roger Bacon writes a[bout] optics and the camera obscura before 1266.

Alhazen is the first to show how an image is formed on the eye, using the camera obscura as an analog. Alhazen states (in the Latin translation), and with respect to the camera obscura, "Et nos non inventimus ita", we did not invent this.

http://www.blight.com/~jno/reclaim/

also...

The camera obscura (Latin for 'dark room') was the ancestor of the modern camera. The camera was actually a large room that would be entered by the user. Light entering a small hole in a darkened room produces an inverted image on the opposite wall. Used initially to view solar eclipses, by the seventeenth century the process was made portable by fitting a lens to one end of a box and using a sheet of glass at the opposite end to view the image. A mirror inserted inside at a 45 degree angle would reverse the image, giving the viewer corrected orientation.

http://www.mc.maricopa.edu/academic/art/arh115/glossary.html


CAM_OBS_LOUVAIN_1544_s.GIF

Camera Obscura, Reinerus Gemma-Frisius, 1544

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography

A larger image is also available

"Reinerus Gemma-Frisius, observed an eclipse of the sun at Louvain on January 24, 1544, and later he used this illustration of the event in his book De Radio Astronomica et Geometrica, 1545. It is thought to be the first published illustration of a camera obscura..."

Hammond, John H., The Camera Obscura, A Chronicle


For centuries, the technique was used for viewing eclipses of the Sun without endangering the eyes and, by the 16th century, as an aid to drawing; the subject was posed outside and the image reflected on a piece of drawing paper for the artist to trace. Portable versions were built, followed by smaller and even pocket models; the interior of the box was painted black and the image reflected by an angled mirror so that it could be viewed right side up.


also...

Latin for 'dark chamber,' and the earliest versions, dating to antiquity, the camera obscura consisted of a small darkened room with light admitted through a single tiny hole. The result was that an inverted image of the outside scene was cast on the opposite wall, which was usually whitened.


also...

Camera Obscura (L. dark chamber), an aid to painting, it consists of a darkened box into which the artist climbed with a small aperture in one wall through which light passes. This image is projected, inverted, onto the wall opposite. Later more sophisticated models added a lens to the aperture, increasing its affinity to the human eye or the photographic camera.

Its strength as an aid to drawing resides in its ability to distil onto a flat surface the confused visual information which strikes the eye. It was much used by Dutch still-life and by topographical painters. Eminent practitioners include the Dutch genre painter Vermeer in the 17th century and the Veduta painter Canaletto in the 18th century.


also...

The term camera obscura is taken from the Latin and means "dark room". Invented in the sixteenth century, the camera obscura is made out of an arrangement of lenses and mirrors in a box that is darkened, The machine permits accuracy in a drawing, often of topographical detail. When looking through the lens of a camera obscura, the view presented is actually reflected through the mirrors onto the paper or cloth and allows the artist to draw by tracing the outline.

Canaletto used one to study his vedute (city views) prior to painting. Carlevaris also made use of the machine for his paintings. It is often quite easy to recognize drawings made using this method, because of the distortion of the edges. A camera lucida is a more complicated instrument that uses a prism. There are examples of both in the Science Museum.

http://www.jonessquare.com/art-square/eoa1/dictfive.html


Athanasius Kircher (1601-1680) (alt: Anastasius) in a book written in 1646, described one [a camera obscura] which consisted of an outer shell with lenses in the centre of each wall, and an inner shell containing transparent paper for drawing; the artist needed to enter by a trapdoor.


CAM_OBS_KIRCHER_1646.GIF

Camera Obscura, Athanasius Kircher, 1646

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


Other versions [of the camera obscura] also appeared. Sedan chairs were converted, and tent-type cameras were also in use - even up the beginning of the nineteen hundreds. Then smaller, portable ones were made. Thus the camera obscura, as it came to be known, became a popular aid to sketching.

Robert Leggat: A History of Photography


CAM_OBS_KEPLER_1620.GIF

Portable 'Tent' Camera Obscura, Johannes Kepler (1571 - 1630), 1620

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


CAM_OBS_ZAHN_1685.GIF

Reflex Camera Obscura, Johannes Zahn, 1685

Originally from Zahn, J., 'Oculus Artificialis', (1685 - 1686)

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


CAM_OBS_1711_s.GIF

Sedan Chair Camera Obscura, William Jakob s'Gravesande, 1711

A larger image is also available

Originally from s' Gravesande, W. J., An Essay on Perspective, 1711

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


CAM_OBS_BRANDER_1769.GIF

Camera Obscura, Georg Friedrich Brander (1713 - 1785), 1769

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


CAM_OBS_BRANDER_1769_D.GIF

Camera Obscura, Georg Friedrich Brander (1713 - 1785), 1769

(cross section detail)

Gernsheim, H., The Origins of Photography


CAM_OBS_1.GIF

Camera Obscura

The above image was frequently copied in such publications as Lardner, Museum of Science and Art,1855. Note the also common irregular depiction of scale between the artist and the camera obscura.


CAM_OBS_1817.GIF

Camera Obscura, 1817

© Jack and Beverly Wilgus The Magic Mirror of Life


CAM_OBS_3.GIF

Camera Obscura, c 1820

English origin. Size: 9" X 4 1/4" X 4 1/4"

© Jack and Beverly Wilgus The Magic Mirror of Life



The final development of the Camera Obscura was as a mass entertainment medium. Large 'Cameras' holding some 10-15 persons were built (often at seaside holiday resorts and outdoor places of entertainment, amusement parks and the like) and the image, transferred from the tower sited lens arrangement, was projected onto a large circular 'table like' 'screen' around which an 'audience' could gather. Being 'live' the image was in colour and it moved and certainly a 'pre' cinema experience in the late 1800's.

Many of these 'Cameras' still exist today and this final development of the camera obscura is extensively detailed on the site The Magic Mirror of Life: by Jack and Beverly Wilgus.


cam_ob_santa_monica.jpg

'Famous Camera Obscura at Santa Monica, Calif'. c.1900

Postcard from a recent auction on eBay


camera_ob_interior.jpg

The Camera Obscura at Central Park, 1877

Frank Leslie's Popular Monthly, 1877 and a recent auction on eBay.


From the investigations of Paul T. Burns on his site The Complete History of Cinematography

A Beginning? - 5th c. B.C.

Mohists knew and taught the linearity of light rays. They knew that light travels in straight lines as did the Greeks at or around the same time. Philosophers Mo Ti (470-391 B.C) also known as Mozu, Motze, Motse, Micius and Mo-Tzu and Chuang Chou (c.369-286 B.C.) commented on the property of shadows.

Mo Ti recorded the observation of an inverted image through a pinhole and talks of the "collecting place" (aperture). He also explains why the image is inverted and uses the analogy of the oar in the rowlock. Mohists knew and taught that objects reflect light and called it "shining forth".


'A Shadow Play' c.121 B.C.

Documented in the 'Shih Chi' and 'Chien Han Shu' of the Han period (ch.28, p24) [Trans., Chavannes, vol.3, p470] is the shadowplay by the magician called Shao Ong who made the spirit (it would appear) of a dead concubine appear to the Emperor Wu. This sort of shadowful illusion was repeated many times throughout Chinese culture and all of Asia.


De Rerum Natura' - c. 60 B.C.

Roman poet and naturalist Lucretius (Titus Lucretius Carus c.98-55 B.C.) combines science and poetry in his De Rerum Natura (On The Nature Of Things, T. L. Carus, IV, 768ff) when he refers to some sort of projection show or dream image in poetic form. Perhaps a shadowplay or something similar to that of Plato. It had been suggested that the work has been incorrectly interpreted.


Peri Automatopoietkes - c.125 A.D.

Heron of Alexandria (also known as Hero) describes in Peri Automatopoietkes (Constructing Automaton Theatres) "phantom mirrors" and "mirror writing." Hero also writes in his 'De Speculis' (the oldest extant Greek writing on mirrors) about concave, convex and plane mirrors. His 'Caoptrica'explains the rectilinear propagation of light and the law of reflection.


Almagest - c.140 A.D.

Ptolemy (Claudius Ptolemaeus fl.127-145 A.D.) accepts Aristotle's view that objects emit light. Ptolemy also writes his Almagest on optics and the universe and speaks of refraction, reflection, persistence of vision and "stereoscopic projection."


Pipe Which Makes Fantasies Appear - c.180 A.D.

The ascending convection of hot air from a lamp caused animals and creatures to appear to move naturally in Ting Huan's "Pipe Which Makes Fantasies Appear." This is perhaps the first account of the marriage of both illumination and movement, created by the same source (lamp).

The Complete History of Cinematography


Aristotle (384 - 322 B.C.) observed the crescent shape of the partially eclipsed sun projected on the ground through the holes of a strainer, and the gaps between the leaves of a tree. He also noticed that the smaller the hole, the sharper the image. In modern cameras, this is analogous to the diaphragm.

Eastman Kodak Timeline of Photography


also...

The Arab mathematician Alhazen first described the magnifying effect of simple lenses in his Book of Optics. He also deduced the linearity of light and told how to 'capture' an eclipse of the sun using a Camera Obscura, from which today's camera takes its name and principle.


also...

The Arabian scholar Hassan ibn Hassan (10th Century A.D.), also known by his Latin name Alhazen, described the Camera Obscura in his writings. Alhazen stressed the significance of the relationship between the size of the aperture and the sharpness of the image. Manuscripts of his observations reside in the India Office Library, London.

Eastman Kodak Timeline of Photography


Further from the investigations of Paul T. Burns...

Camera Obscura - c.10th c.A.D.

Yu Chao Lung builds miniature pagodas to observe the pinhole images through a hole onto a screen and therefore learns of the divergence of light rays using a camera obscura.


Camera Obscura - c.1086

Shen Kua talks of the camera obscura's inverted image, the collecting place, burning mirrors and the focal point.


Plano-convex lenses - c.1220

Robert Grosseteste (1175-1253) a contemporary of Roger Bacon used plano-convex lenses.


Meng Liang Lu - 12th c.

Further examples of illumination and movement are mentioned in the Meng Liang Lu written by the Chinese scholars Chiang Khuei and Fang Cheng during the Sung dynasty. In poetic form they describe "how the horses prance around after the lamp is lit." Similar entries tell "how the smoke gives life and spirit to the figures in the "lanthorn" where they seem to walk, turn, ascend and descend."

Clearly, motion is represented when it describes horses "running", vessels "sailing", and armies "marching". These celebrated incidents in Chinese culture are referred to by both Hangchow (1275 A.D.) who also talks of the "flying dragons", and Gabriel Magalhaens (c.1650).


De Multiplicatione Specierum - 1267

Roger Bacon (1214-1294), proponent of medieval science writes in his treatise De Multiplicatione Specierum (Book II, ch.viii) and Perspectiva, the principle of the camera obscura. He talks of observing the view outside a dark room, and eclipses by way of a ray of light passing through an aperture and projecting itself. Bacon speaks of the camera obscura effect but does not describe the apparatus.


Almanac - 1285 (1290)

French astronomer Guillaume De Saint-Cloud (c.1290) writes in an almanac the impairment of the eyes if the eclipse (in this case June 5, 1285) is viewed for too long. In some cases, spectators complained of near blindness for several days, others for hours. This manuscript was dated five years later in 1290.

In order to eliminate this loss of vision, Saint-Cloud went on to explain the use of the camera obscura for viewing the sun during an eclipse. The camera obscura continued to be a useful tool for watching eclipses. Like Archimedes, Saint-Cloud talked of the power of lenses and mirrors.


'Moving Shows' - c.1290

Arnaud De Villeneuve (1238-1314) Also known as Arnold of Villanova, was a practising physician and wrote on alchemy. A magician and showman in his leisure time, Villeneuve used the camera obscura to present "moving shows" or "cinema" by placing his audiences in the darkened room and would have the actors perform outside. The image of the performance would be cast on the inside wall. Villeneuve would often enact wars, or the hunting of animals with the actual noises of such, which would be heard from inside.

The Complete History of Cinematography


Around 1519, Leonardo da Vinci (1452 - 1519) wrote:

"When images of illuminated objects ... penetrate through a small hole into a very dark room ... you will see [on the opposite wall] these objects in their proper form and color, reduced in size ... in a reversed position, owing to the intersection of the rays".

Szarkowski, J., Photography until Now


also...

Later in the 16th century, Giovani Battista della Porta of Naples wrote in his book Natural Magic (1558):

"If you cannot paint, you can by this arrangement [camera obscura] draw [outlines of images] with a pencil. You will have then only to lay on the colors".

Upton and Upton, Photography

also...

Even people who could paint, like Canaletto (1697-1768) and Holland's Jan Vermeer (1632-75), were believed to have used the Camera Obscura as an aid, although there is no proof.


The forerunner of the camera was the Camera Obscura, a dark chamber or room with a hole (later a lens) in one wall through which images of objects outside the room were projected on the opposite wall. The principle was probably known to Aristotle more than 2,000 years ago.

The Italian scientist and writer Giambattista della Porta, late in the 16th century, demonstrated and described in detail the use of a camera obscura with a lens. By the 18th century artists commonly used various types of Camera Obscura to trace accurate images from nature. These devices still depended on the artist's drawing skills, however, and the search for a method to reproduce images completely mechanically continued.


The Camera Obscura (Latin for Dark room) was a dark box or room with a hole in one end. If the hole was small enough, an inverted image would be seen on the opposite wall. Such a principle was known by thinkers as early as Aristotle (c.300 BC).

It is said that Roger Bacon invented the camera obscura just before the year 1300 (1267 - observed eclipses in a 'natural room' http://photoscope.com), but this has never been accepted by scholars; more plausible is the claim that he used one to observe solar eclipses.

The earliest record of the uses of a camera obscura can be found in the writings of Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519). At about the same period Daniel Barbaro, a Venetian, recommended the camera as an aid to drawing and perspective. He wrote:

"Close all shutters and doors until no light enters the camera except through the lens, and opposite hold a piece of paper, which you move forward and backward until the scene appears in the sharpest detail. There on the paper you will see the whole view as it really is, with its distances, its colours and shadows and motion, the clouds, the water twinkling, the birds flying. By holding the paper steady you can trace the whole perspective with a pen, shade it and delicately colour it from nature".

In the mid sixteenth century Giovanni Battista della Porta (1538-1615) published what is believed to be the first account of the possibilities as an aid to drawing. It is said that he made a huge "camera" in which he seated his guests, having arranged for a group of actors to perform outside so that the visitors could observe the images on the wall.

The story goes, however, that the sight of up-side down performing images was too much for the visitors; they panicked and fled, and Battista was later brought to court on a charge of sorcery! Though Battista's account is wrapped up in a study of the occult, it is likely that from that time onwards many artists will have used a camera obscura to aid them in drawing, though either because of the association with the occult, or because they felt that in some way their artistry was lessened, few would admit to using one.

Several are said to have used them; these include Giovanni Canale - better known as Canaletto (1697- 1768), Jan Vermeer (1632-1675), Joshua Reynolds (1723-1792), and Paul Sandby (1725-1809), a founding member of the Royal Academy. Though some, including Joshua Reynolds, warned against the indiscriminate use of the camera obscura, others, notably Algarotti, a writer on art and science and a highly influential man amongst artists, strongly advocated its use in his Essays on Painting (1764):

"the best modern painters among the Italians have availed themselves of this contrivance; nor is it possible that they should have otherwise represented things so much to the life... Let the young painter, therefore, begin as early as possible to study these divine pictures"...."Painters should make the same use of the Camera Obscura, which Naturalists and Astronomers make of the microscope and telescope; for all these instruments equally contribute to make known, and represent Nature."

About the same time, the lens was being developed. Once again Roger Bacon's name is associated with this; some have claimed that it was he who invented spectacles. Gerolomo Cardano (1501-1576), an Italian mathematician, introduced a glass disc in place of a pinhole in his camera, and Barbaro also used a convex lens. Why the name lens? It is claimed that because Italian lenses were by-convex, they seemed to resemble the brown lentils the used to make soup - so the lens came from the Latin for lentil.


The camera obscura, or dark chamber , was popular with prominent scientists, artists, and wealthy people during the mid-1600s. It was often highlighted by travelling natural magic shows which played to public audiences. The camera obscura worked by allowing light from a small hole to enter a dark room. An image from the outside was projected onto a wall or surface parallel to the plane of focus. The artist placed paper on the surface to sketch or trace the image.

In more complex versions, a mirror was used to re invert the inverted image and lenses were added to aid in focusing. A prominent Dutch physicist and astronomer, Constantijn Huygens (1596-1678) introduced and demonstrated the camera obscura to many Dutch artists.

The camera obscura is frequently associated with the works of Jan Vermeer a Dutch artist, born in 1632, and often called Vermeer van Delft to distinguish him from an earlier Jan Vermeer. He lived in the town of Delft his entire life. Vermeer, a painstaking worker, produced only about 40 known paintings.

His paintings were known for their soft light and slightly blurred outlines. His work is also associated with the camera obscura, although recently his use of this device has come into question. The perspective of his paintings was so precise, however, that computer models of his room have been generated, adding substance to the theory he used the camera obscura in his work.

A New Perspective on Science and Art


Further from the investigations of Paul T. Burns...

Treatise on Painting - 1457

Leon Battista Alberti (1398 [1404?]-1472 [1484?]) Vasari, in his 'Lives of the Painters, Sculptors and Architects' tells us of Alberti;

"Leon Battista made a discovery for representing landscapes and for diminshing and enlarging figures by means of an instrument, all good inventions useful to art."

This instrument was actually Alberti's Intersector (a cousin to the camera lucida), and not a camera obscura. Alberti describes this technique in his 'Treatise on Painting'. Vasari's work also contains details of a show box (Vite de' Piu Eccellenti Architetti e Scultori, Vasari, G., Milan, Italy, 1809, vol.5, p81) where painted pictures on transparent bases were illuminated from behind by candles. This description closely resembles (and pre-dates) the magic lanterns of Drebbel and Kircher.


Gainsborough's Showbox - 15th c.

During the 15th century, William Gainsborough painted many landscapes (perhaps for Alberti) on glass and made similar apparatti (show boxes) to that of Alberti. These boxes were wooden and had peep-holes at one side. The opposite end was open and had the glass-painted slide inserted and lit from behind by candles. A Gainsborough showbox is [on display] at the Victoria and Albert Museum, London.


Treatise On Architecture - 1521

What could be the earliest published description of the camera obscura (Vinci's works were not published until 1797 when deciphered by Venturi) is found in Vitruvius's Treatise On Architecture (10 volumes, Trans. by Caesare Caesariano (1483-1543) , Como, Italy, 1521, Book 1, Leaf 23, verso).

Caesariano was a student under Leonardo da Vinci and through the work of Vitruvius, describes a passage detailing an experiment by an unknown Benedictine monk, Papnutio, or Paunce.

The entry tells of the use of a cone-shaped hole (or tube) in the wall, in order to allow more light and therefore a larger image on the opposite white wall. A concave glass screen is also mentioned being placed in the hole of a wall in a darkened room. Like the style of Leonardo Da Vinci, Papnutio gives exact dimensions in his account of the camera obscura.

Unfortunately, Caesariano does not give dates of the experiment. Thirty years later, Giovanni Battista Della Porta will speak of the camera in astonishingly similar terms and claims for his own the idea of using lenses under the pretense of "secrets".

Hermann Hecht's Pre-Cinema History (3) notes inability to trace Papnutio


Underweysung - 1525

German artist Albrecht Durer (1471-1528) made woodcuts of drawing aids, one of which was his own and published them in his Underweysung in 1525. His illustrations show telescopic, or sighting tubes and grids used by the artist.


Theoricae Novae Planetarum - c.1540-1545

German mathematician and astronomer Erasmus Reinhold (1511-1553) made observations of solar eclipses using a pinhole camera, and explained how to use the camera to view the eclipse. Reinhold tells of two eclipses that took place in 1544 (a solar eclipse of January 24, 1544 was illustrated and described by Frisius) and 1545. Reinhold's Theoricae Novae Planetarum of Georg Pauerbach, mentions that not only can one observe an eclipse, but also "things in the street."


De Subtilitate Libri - 1550

Girolamo Cardano (1501-1576), a professor of mathematics and a physician, published in his book De Subtilitate Libri (XXI, Cardani, Nurnberg, 1550, Book IV, p107) his makings of a camera obscura with a diverting spectacle and a very graphic description of darkroom pictures and their appearances.

Cardano appears also to have initiated the use of a convex lens in the aperture. Cardano was a showman, and projected wild scenes of the outdoors along with appropriate sound effects to audiences in the camer obscura (see Villeneuve, c.1290). In 1570, Cardano was accused of heresy, jailed, and lost his right to publish books.


Magiae Naturalis Libri - c.1553-1558

Giovanni Battista Della Porta (1538-1615), gave elaborate details in physics, alchemy, astronomy, magic, cooking, perfumes, toiletry and optics in his Magiae Naturalis Libri (III, vol.4, Porta, Naples, Italy, 1558). This first work (also see 1588) by the Neopolitan scientist Porta, was a popular piece of scientific literature in the sixteenth century and in book 2, chapter 3, Porta gives a thorough description of a camera obscura and the images that one would see. From about this point on, the camera obscura would become a useful tool to artists.


La Practtica Della Perspecttiva - 1568

Venetian nobleman and architect Daniel Barabaro describes the use of a biconvex lens in the camera obscura in his La Practtica Della Perspecttiva (Barbaro, Venice, Italy, 1568, ch.5, p192). As did Giovanni Batista Della Porta, Barbaro suggested the use of the camera obscura to the painter. In describing the use of the convex lens, he shows that the image is much sharper and can therefore be outlined by a pencil.

The Complete History of Cinematography


From a photgraphic newsgroup...

The first documented case of a camera obscura being used, as far as my research indicates, is that of Fillipo Brunelleschi in 1425. (For an interesting discussion see Shigeru Tsuji, Brunelleschi and the camera obscura: the discovery of pictorial perspective, Art History vol. 13, Sep. 1990, pp. 276-292.)

There may still be some debate about whether Brunelleschi used a camera obscura but to my mind his argument is convincing. James Snyder (author of Medieval and Northern Renaissance Art) has said that camera obscuras were quite popular with landscape painters right around the time of Rembrandt, which would be quite in period.

Raedwynne aet thaem Grene Wudu


As for the camera obscura... Depends on what form of it you mean. The period ones (invented by an Italian born in 1540) consist of two rooms with, at first, a small hole between them. The room with the subject would be brightly lit, while the room with the artist would be quite dark. Using a lens in the opening between the two rooms is documentable to 1598--just barely period.

Hal Heydt


A while back someone asked about construction of a camera obscura. At the time I had little in the way of suggestions, even though I had been looking for such myself. However, this past week I came upon a great work. Hermann Hecht's, Pre-Cinema History. An Encyclopaedia and Annotated Bibliography of the Moving Image Before 1896 (London: Bowker-Saur, 1993). It is "Published in Association with the British Film Institute".

The earliest work mentioned that I have found on cursory examination is from the 1st century BC. There are many from the 16th century, and some from the 15th century and before. One must really read through some of the entries to get a real feel for what this bibliography is all about.

Vajk

http://www.pbm.com/~lindahl/rialto/p-cameras-msg.html


Photography: History and Development

Photography as it is known today originated in the early 19th century when Frenchman Joseph Nicephore Niepce managed to fix a crude image on a pewter plate. With the synthesis of three emerging technologies-optics, mechanics and chemistry-it might seem that photography came into being overnight. Yet its origins reach far beyond Niepce and back to the dawn of human awareness.

As early as the fourth century BC (circa 336-323 BC), Aristotle described a method for viewing a solar eclipse without damaging the eye. If a metal plate punched with small holes was held up to the sun, he said, then a corresponding image of the sun could be projected through it and onto the ground. The method was not novel to Aristotle, and likely well established before he wrote about it. This simple optical principle is the foundation of photography.

The Camera Obscura

In 1038 AD, an Arab scholar named Alhazan described a working model of the camera obscura. Literally meaning dark chamber, the camera obscura was a room or box lit only by a small hole that admitted sunshine. Light rays poured through the hole, eerily assembling an image of the outside world on the opposite wall.

Although Alhazan did not actually construct the device, his work would influence a medieval tinkerer named Roger Bacon. In 1267 AD, Bacon created convincing optical illusions by using mirrors and the basic principles of the camera obscura. Later, he used a camera obscura to project an image of the sun directly upon an opposite wall.

Throughout the middle ages, Bacon's ideas were adapted for astronomical observations of the sun. The camera obscura became a popular tool for safely studying eclipses.

It was not until the Renaissance that the instrument was widely used as a drawing tool. Although Leonardo Da Vinci is popularly credited for using the camera obscura to draw, that is only partially true. A student of physiology, Da Vinci built a small camera obscura to test his theories about the workings of the human eye and the concept of perspective. Da Vinci never used the camera obscura to draw. Without a lens, the camera was not a very effective or portable tool for viewing the world.

The introduction of the orbem e vitro, a kind of primitive biconvex lens, revolutionized the utility of the camera obscura. Like the lens that C. C. Harrison and J. Schinitzler would perfect in 1860, the orbem was constructed of two convex lenses. The design reduced distortion and increased clarity. Although no inventor is known, the lens was first mentioned by Girolamo Cardano, a Milanese mathematics professor, in the 1550 edition of his scientific encyclopedia.

In 1558 the Neapolitan scientist Giovanni Battista della Porta suggested the camera obscura would make a wondrous aid to artists. In his Magiae Naturalis, he discussed the applications to portraiture, landscapes, and the copying of other paintings. With the lens, he wrote, "You will see everything clearer, the faces of men walking in the street, the colors, clothes, and everything as if you stood nearby."

Another notable improvement came in 1568 when Daniele Barbaro, a Venetian nobleman, described a camera obscura outfitted with a lens and diaphragm. This forerunner of the aperture could be made progressively smaller so the image would become ever sharper. With continuing improvements in optics, the camera obscura no longer needed a large, stationary room to create an image.

In 1572 Friedrich Risner constructed a small hut that could be carried around the countryside and used to make topographical drawings. Camera obscuras began to shrink in size and improve in optical quality. By 1657, camera obscuras were small enough to be carried under one arm. During the latter half of the 17th century, they proliferated across Europe, with uses as varied as painting, architectural drawing and spying.

As remarkable as the instruments were, they didn't fully satisfy the needs of artists. While canvas painting is a vertical pursuit, many artists preferred to sketch a scene on a laptop pad. In 1676, Johann Christoph Sturm, a professor of mathematics at Altdorf University in Germany, introduced a reflex mirror. Mounted at a 45 degree angle from the lens, the mirror projected the image to a screen above. This elegant configuration is at the core of modern single lens reflex cameras.

In 1685, Johann Zahn, a monk from Wurzburg, solved the final piece in the optical puzzle. Improving upon Sturm's design, he introduced lenses of longer and shorter focal lengths. Scenes as wide as a landscape or as close as a portrait could be viewed with a simple change of lens. He also painted the interior of his camera obscura black to avoid internal reflections.

Excepting a mechanical shutter, Zahn's invention was the prototype for today's camera. Yet it would be over one hundred and fifty years before the camera obscura and photosensitive chemicals were combined to make permanent photographs.

http://www.digitalcentury.com/encyclo/update/photo_hd.html


Vermeer and Camera Obscura

camr_ob1.jpg

"The Girl with a Pearl Earring"
c. 1665
The Hague, Mauritshuis
Courtesy of Roy Williams

Johannes (sometimes Jan) Vermeer (1632-1675) was a painter who could capture an image that was camera-like in its detail and quality. His full name is Jan van der Meer van Delft and he lived his entire 43-year life in the Dutch city of Delft. The "van Delft" was added to his name to distinguish him from an earlier Jan Vermeer.

Only 35 of his paintings survive. You can see all thirty-five fabulous Vermeer paintings at a website brought to you by Roy Williams of Caltech at Pasadena, California. Vermeer was a great master who produced paintings that to this day instill awe by their captivating reality. Yet, upon closer examination, the paintings are a modified reality designed through the manipulation of light, shadow, blur and perspective to make the flat image on the canvas trick the eye into believing it is a precise modern-day snapshot.


When the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. assembled 23 of Johannes Vermeer's works at the end of 1995 and the beginning of 1996, the exhibition was an immediate sellout success. The National Gallery currently has four Vermeers on its website: Girl with a Flute c. 1665/1670, Girl with the Red Hat c. 1665/1666, A Lady Writing c. 1665 and, Woman Holding a Balance c. 1664. For many, his paintings were enthralling. Seven of the National Gallery's Vermeer exhibition, along with explanatory text, are reproduced by texas.net Museum of Art, Glyphs Online Magazine.camr_ob8.jpg

"Woman Holding a Balance"
c.1664
Courtesy of
National Gallery of Art


Camera Obscura

A discussion of Vermeer's works would itself be an interesting and encompassing task. However, it may perhaps be as intriguing to discuss Vermeer's technique, that is, the probable use of the Camera Obscura to reproduce blur in the way he did. The term Camera Obscura means dark room in Latin.

Camera Obscura can be likened to a modern day camera that doesn't require a lens or film; the device projects an inverted image onto a wall or canvas. The Chinese first discovered in the 5th century B.C. that if one made a small hole in the wall of a darkened room, an inverted image of the outside is projected from the pinhole to the wall opposite the small hole. No matter the distance to the opposite wall, the image of the outside was projected onto it. Shorten or lengthen the distance to change the size of the projection.A Camera Obscura image
taken from a converted lighthouse in the United Kingdom.
camr_ob5.jpg

Courtesy of
Virtual Portmeirion
Portmerion Village
Penrhyndeudraeth
Gwynedd, North Wales


Aristotle independently discovered some of the puzzling elements of the Camera Obscura c. 300 B.C. while studying an eclipse. He noticed, but couldn't explain, that during a partial eclipse of the sun, the openings between the leaves of a tree cast images of the sun on the ground. But it wasn't until the Renaissance when Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) describes a Camera Obscura for use in creating art. It apparently became a popular artistic tool as was recommended by artist Daniel Barbaro, a Venetian in a writing about the technique.

A prominent Dutch physicist and astronomer, Constantijn Huygens (1596-1678) introduced and demonstrated the Camera Obscura to many Dutch artists, including Vermeer. Numerous artists through the 19th century, in addition to Vermeer, used the device as an aid to drawing, including Giovanni Canale, aka Canaletto (1697-1768), Joshua Reynolds (1723-1792), and Paul Sandby (1725-1809), a founding member of the Royal Academy.

You can find an excellent discussion of the history of the pinhole concept at this Massachusetts Institute of Technology site. And if you would like to do some experiments on your own, this educational site will provide some simple directions.


camr_ob4.jpg

Camera Obscura
San Francisco, California
Courtesy of
Bay Area Backroads
by KRON-TV

Now almost completely lost as a technique, it is hard to believe that the Camera Obscura became so popular during the 16th-19th centuries that traveling magic shows offered it to public audiences for amusement. Camera Obscura houses were built in this country and in Europe to attract the tourist dollar. One still exists (shown on the left) as a tourist attraction on the cliffs at Ocean Beach in northwest San Francisco.

At the end of the 19th century, there were three types of Camera Obscura: 1) a darkened room with a lens and a mirror in the roof which produced an image on a table; 2) a portable tent with a lens and a mirror at the apex of the tent which produced an image on a table; and, 3) a portable box with a pinhole on one side and a translucent paper on the opposite wall. This last type was the forerunner of the modern camera.


On the East Coast, New York's Central Park and Philadelphia both had Camera Obscura attractions in the late 19th century. They were popularly viewed as educational and entertaining, but also came to symbolize the voyeur: to see without being seen, to devilishly spy on those who thought they were alone. You can see post card images of these attractions at the Jack and Beverly Wilgus' site.

If you are interested in visiting Camera Obscura buildings in Great Britain, London's Science Museum Web Pages has a page listing 10 locations.

camr_ob6.jpg

19th Century Cartoon
depicting Camera Obscura
Courtesy of
Jack and Beverly Wilgus

Vermeer and Camera Obscura

camr_ob2.jpg

"The Girl with the Red Hat"
c. 1665
National Gallery of Art
Courtesy of Glyphs

Vermeer is thought to have used Camera Obscura for "The Girl with a Red Hat." This is one of his smaller paintings (9" x 7") on a wood panel. The highlights of the lion head chair finial appear as if it were the unfocused effect of an image seen in a Camera Obscura. Vermeer had to have altered the Camera Obscura image. The left chair finial is larger than it ought to be and it is angled to the right. Also, if the chair top is extended to the left, it is misaligned with the finial. Finally, Vermeer altered the chairback to provide space for the girl's arm.

The "View of the Delft" is one of Vermeer's most celebrated paintings. It is thought that Camera Obscura was used to develop the scene and that artistic modifications were made. Vermeer flattened the cityscape, compressed some it, and stretched the horizontals of the buildings, walls and bridge. The boat on the water at the right shimmers with reflected light from the water. Yet, the water and the boat are in shadow. Vermeer is almost unrivaled in his mastery of color, perspective and shadow.camr_ob3.jpg

"View of Delft"
c. 1660-1661
Royal Cabinet of Paintings
Mauritshuis The Hague
Courtesy of Roy Williams


The techniques of the great masters varied considerably and many probably used the latest scientific techniques to instill a realism in their work. While it cannot be asserted without doubt, it is generally agreed that Vermeer used the Camera Obscura as an aid in painting. Regardless of what aids he might have used, his work is among the best in the history of art. He captured a realism and detail that frequently causes the fortunate viewer to gaze in wonder at the beauty of his work.

http://www.fineanddecorativeart.com


An in-depth technical examination of Vermeer's 'Music Lesson' by Professor Philip Steadman clearly supports the argument that Vermeer indeed used a camera obscura.

Taken from a draft published on his home page, Professor Steadman writes, in part...

"For more than a hundred years it has been suggested by art historians that the painter Johannes Vermeer (1632-1675) used the camera obscura as an aid to composition." [...] "Up until recently the belief that Vermeer might have worked in this way has rested on analysis of certain characteristics of the artist's style. (There is no independent documentary evidence of his working methods. Vermeer's perspective has seemed to certain critics to be `photographic'; he reproduces some real objects such as actual maps, and paintings by other artists, with great precision; and most tellingly, he renders certain passages 'out of focus'. The suggestion here is that he is copying artifacts of slightly deficient lenses."

Now Professor Philip Steadman has thrown new light on this old subject, through a perspective analysis of some twelve pictures by Vermeer, all of which apparently show the same room." [...] "Professor Steadman has had a scale model of the room constructed with which to test this hypothesis. A plate camera takes the role of Vermeer's camera, with its lens at the painting's theoretical viewpoint, and its plate in the plane of the back wall. This model has been used to recreate a number of Vermeer's compositions photographically.[...] It turns out that all the dimensions from the various reconstructions are compatible. This is the same room throughout. The theoretical viewpoint of each picture can be located within the space of the room."

Vermeer's Camera by Professor Philip Steadman http://www.grand-illusions.com/vermeer1.htm


Further Reading:

Online

The Magic Mirror of Life: by Jack and Beverly Wilgus

The Camera Obscura and Its Subject: by Jonathan Crary

The Sky in a Room: how to build your own 'true' Camera Obscura

Offline

The Camera Obscura, A Chronicle: by John Hammond, 1981, ISBN 085274451X


and finally, from Robert Rigby...

The principles of the pinhole camera probably date back to the ancient Greeks, but by the 16th century specially constructed portable darkrooms (or camera obscuras which is derived from Italian meaning "room dark" or dark room) were in quite common use by landscape painters.

With their understanding of focusing an image onto a translucent material using a pin hole, they literally traced the local scenery to form the basis of their paintings. It is thought that the Dutch painter, Vermeer, used a camera obscura for many of his paintings. It only took another two hundred years for someone to come along and find the method of "trapping" this focused image onto a photographic materials.

Obviously pinhole photography has one or two limitations, such as exposure times and framing, but these are outweighed by the simplicity and low cost approach to producing creative images.

rigby_pinhole.jpg

The Robert Rigby Pinhole Camera

"A modern approach to a 'classic' concept"


Back to the Top | Essays Index | Quit | eMail: Dr Russell Naughton